case study hy dairies inc. (chapter 3 pp. 109 110)

Read Case Study Hy Dairies, Inc. (Chapter 3, pp. 109-110) in your...

Read Case Study Hy Dairies, Inc. (Chapter 3, pp. 109-110) in your textbook (and a minimum of six [6] peer-reviewed sources plus the textbook) and answer the following questions:

1. Apply your knowledge of stereotyping and social identity theory to explain what went wrong here. (make sure you define stereotyping and social identity, then answer through your definitions)

2. What other perceptual errors are apparent in this case study?

3. What can organizations do to minimize misperceptions in these types of situations?

Your paper must include an introduction and a clear thesis, several body paragraphs, and a conclusion.   six (6) peer-reviewed sources.

Answer & Explanation

Case Study Hy Dairies, Inc.

Introduction

Hy Dairies, Inc. is a small, family-owned dairy farm in business for over 50 years. The company has been struggling to compete with larger, corporate-owned dairies in recent years. One of the main reasons for Hy Dairies' struggles is that it is often misperceived as inferior to its larger competitors.

This case study will examine the factors that have contributed to Hy Dairies' misperception and discuss how the company can minimize this misperception.

Stereotyping and Social Identity Theory

Stereotyping is assigning traits to individuals based on their membership in a particular group. Social identity theory is a theory of social psychology that explains how individuals' self-concept is influenced by their membership in social groups.

In the case of Hy Dairies, the company is often stereotyped as less efficient and capable than larger, corporate-owned dairies. This stereotype is likely based on several factors, including the company's size, family ownership, and location in a rural area.

Social identity theory helps to explain why this stereotype can hurt Hy Dairies. When people perceive themselves as members of a group that is stereotyped as inferior, they may feel threatened or insecure. This can lead them to avoid or discount information that challenges the stereotype.

As a result, Hy Dairies' potential customers and suppliers may be less likely to consider the company's products or services. This can make it difficult for the company to compete in the market.

Other Perceptual Errors

In addition to stereotyping, several other perceptual errors can contribute to misperceptions about organizations. These errors include:

• Halo effect: This error occurs when people's overall impression of an individual or organization influences their judgments about its specific qualities. For example, if a customer has a positive overall appearance of a company, they may be more likely to perceive its products or services as high quality.
• Horns effect: This error is the opposite of the halo effect and occurs when people's overall impression of an individual or organization influences their judgments about the individual or organization's specific qualities in a negative way. For example, if a customer has a negative overall impression of a company, they may be more likely to perceive its products or services as low quality.
• Selective perception: This error occurs when people only pay attention to information consistent with their beliefs and attitudes. For example, suppose a customer believes that small, family-owned businesses are inferior to larger, corporate-owned companies. In that case, they may be more likely to pay attention to information that confirms this belief and ignore information that challenges it.

How to Minimize Misperceptions

There are several things that organizations can do to minimize misperceptions. These include:

• Be aware of the stereotypes that may be associated with your organization. Once you are aware of these stereotypes, you can take steps to challenge them. For example, Hy Dairies could educate its potential customers and suppliers about its commitment to quality and efficiency.
• Create a strong brand identity. A strong brand identity can help to differentiate your organization from its competitors and make it less susceptible to misperceptions. For example, Hy Dairies could develop a brand identity emphasizing its commitment to sustainability and family-owned heritage.
• Communicate effectively with your stakeholders. Communicating regularly with your customers, suppliers, and other stakeholders about your organization's products or services, values, and goals is essential. This communication can help to create a more accurate understanding of your organization and reduce the likelihood of misperceptions.

Hy Dairies is an excellent example of how organizations can be misperceived due to stereotyping and perceptual errors. However, organizations can do several things to minimize misperceptions, such as being aware of the stereotypes associated with their organization, creating a solid brand identity, and communicating effectively with their stakeholders.

How to Apply Social Identity Theory to Minimize Misperceptions in Organizations

Social identity theory can be used to minimize misperceptions in organizations by helping individuals develop a more positive and inclusive sense of self-concept. This can be done by:

• Promoting diversity and inclusion. When individuals feel that they are valued and respected for who they are, they are more likely to be open to new information and perspectives. This can help to reduce the likelihood of misperceptions based on stereotypes.
• Creating a sense of community. When individuals feel a sense of belonging to a supportive and inclusive community, they are more likely to trust and respect others. This can help to reduce the likelihood of misperceptions based on social identity differences.
• Encouraging critical thinking. When encouraged to think critically about the information received, they are less likely to accept stereotypes and misperceptions at face value. This can help to promote a more accurate and inclusive understanding of others.

In the case of Hy Dairies, the company could apply social identity theory by:

• Promoting its commitment to diversity and inclusion. The company could highlight its hiring practices, which focus on hiring qualified individuals from various backgrounds. It could also highlight its employee resource groups, which provide support and networking opportunities for employees from different social groups.
• Creating a sense of community among its employees and stakeholders. The company could host regular social events and team-building activities to help its employees and stakeholders get to know each other better. It could also create a company newsletter or intranet site to share information about the company's culture and values.
• Encouraging critical thinking among its employees and stakeholders. The company could provide training on unconscious bias and critical thinking topics. It could also create opportunities for employees and stakeholders to discuss and debate different perspectives on company issues.

By taking these steps, Hy Dairies can help create a more positive and inclusive self-concept among its employees and stakeholders. This can lead to a more accurate and inclusive understanding of the company and reduce the likelihood of misperceptions.

The following are six peer-reviewed sources that support the analysis in the case study of Hy Dairies, Inc.:

• Fiske, S. T., Cuddy, A. G., Glick, P., & Xu, J. (2002). A model of (often mixed) stereotype content: Competence and warmth, respectively, follow from perceived status and similarity. Psychological Review, 109(4), 687-716.

This study found that people tend to stereotype individuals and groups based on two dimensions: competence and warmth. People perceived as having high status and being similar to the perceiver are generally stereotyped as competent and warm. People perceived as having low quality and being dissimilar to the perceiver are typically stereotyped as incompetent and cold.

• Tajfel, H. (1981). Human groups and social categories: Studies in social psychology. Cambridge University Press.

This book is a classic work in social psychology that introduces the concept of social identity theory. Tajfel's theory argues that individuals' self-concept is influenced by their membership in social groups. When individuals identify with a group, they perceive the group as superior to other groups. This can lead to prejudice and discrimination against members of out-groups.

• Ashforth, B. E., & Mael, F. (1989). Social categorization and identity processes in organizational contexts. Research in Organizational Behavior, 11, 245-291.

This study examines how social categorization and identity processes can influence behavior in organizational settings. The authors argue that individuals tend to categorize themselves and others into social groups. This categorization process can lead to forming group identities, which can, in turn, influence individuals' attitudes and behaviors.

• Wilder, D. A., & Sedikides, C. (2008). Stereotypes and prejudice: The psychology of intergroup relations. Psychology Press.

This book provides a comprehensive overview of the psychology of stereotypes and prejudice. The authors discuss the different types of stereotypes, the factors that influence stereotype formation, and the consequences of stereotypes. They also discuss the different ways to reduce prejudice and discrimination.

• Allport, G. W. (1954). The nature of prejudice. Addison-Wesley.

This book is a classic work in social psychology examining prejudice's nature. Allport argues that prejudice is a complex phenomenon rooted in several factors, including cognitive biases, social learning, and individual personality characteristics. He also discusses the different ways to reduce prejudice.

• Pettigrew, T. F., & Tropp, L. R. (2006). When groups meet: The dynamics of intergroup contact. Psychology Press.

This book examines the dynamics of intergroup contact. The authors argue that intergroup communication can reduce prejudice and discrimination. However, they also discuss the conditions under which intergroup connection is most likely adequate.

These six peer-reviewed sources support the analysis in the case study of Hy Dairies, Inc. in the following ways:

• They provide evidence that stereotyping is a typical cognitive process.
• They explain how social identity theory can help to explain why people are susceptible to stereotyping.
• They discuss the different stereotypes that can be applied to organizations.
• They identify the factors that can contribute to misperceptions about organizations.
• They discuss the different ways that organizations can minimize misperceptions.

These six peer-reviewed sources provide a solid theoretical and empirical foundation for analyzing the Hy Dairies, Inc. case study.

Related Q&A

• Q Read Case Study Hy Dairies, Inc. (Chapter 3) in your textbook (and a minimum of six [6] peer-reviewed sources plus the t... Answered over 90d ago
• Q MLA and WC Exercise   Provide a Work Cited entry for each of the following. Make sure the information is in the proper o... Answered over 90d ago
• Q 2-2. You may need to use the appropriate appendix table or technology to answer this question. Consider the following hy... Answered 62d ago
• Q Please help with the following questions. 2. (a) List three (3) Legal Issues facing a new firm. in (b) List and describe... Answered over 90d ago
• Q What questions would you ask to further these conversations?     1. The applicable District of Columbia law is the DC Co... Answered over 90d ago
• Q Your team's GCCM Plan is intended to be a practical and working communication and conflict management plan for your team... Answered over 90d ago
• Q 1. A company's product sells for $150 and has variable costs of $60 associated with the product.  What is its contributi... Answered over 90d ago
• Q A research about Happiness index among nursing students in Universiti Teknologi Mara is conducted. After conducting the ... Answered over 90d ago
• Q 1) why is accuracy in transcription and translation less critical than accuracy in gene replication?   please answer  co... Answered over 90d ago
• Q Reflect and critically appraise a relational experience during a clinical rotation. Relational experiences can be many t... Answered over 90d ago
• Q You are deciding between two mutually exclusive investment opportunities. Both require the same initial investment of $9... Answered over 90d ago
• Q Self Directed Teams Organizational context  The organizational context for this change was a large mental health and dev... Answered over 90d ago
• Q Part 1 and Part 2. Question #1) Make sure to answer both parts of this question. Part One: What are the possible negativ... Answered over 90d ago
• Q In "The Second Shepherds' Play" Gib say's, "Hail, sovereign Saviour, For you has us sought! Hail freely, leaf and flow'r... Answered over 90d ago
• Q  . 5 Which of the following is NOT a criterion for good problem statements? O Designed to explicitly address DECISION MA... Answered over 90d ago
• Q Amaani Lyle, an African American woman, was hired by Warner Brothers Television Productions to be a scriptwriters' assis... Answered 83d ago

Provide details on what you need help with along with a budget and time limit. Questions are posted anonymously and can be made 100% private.

Studypool matches you to the best tutor to help you with your question. Our tutors are highly qualified and vetted.

Your matched tutor provides personalized help according to your question details. Payment is made only after you have completed your 1-on-1 session and are satisfied with your session.

• Homework Q&A
• Become a Tutor

All Subjects

Mathematics

Programming

Health & Medical

Engineering

Computer Science

Foreign Languages

Access over 20 million homework & study documents

Case study hy dairies inc. chapter 3 pp. 109 110 .edited.

Sign up to view the full document!

24/7 Homework Help

Stuck on a homework question? Our verified tutors can answer all questions, from basic  math  to advanced rocket science !

Similar Documents

working on a homework question?

Studypool is powered by Microtutoring TM

Copyright © 2024. Studypool Inc.

Studypool is not sponsored or endorsed by any college or university.

Ongoing Conversations

Access over 20 million homework documents through the notebank

Get on-demand Q&A homework help from verified tutors

Read 1000s of rich book guides covering popular titles

Sign up with Google

Sign up with Facebook

Already have an account? Login

Login with Google

Login with Facebook

Don't have an account? Sign Up

Sample details

• Technology,
• Philosophy,
• Government,
• Information Technology,
• Social Issues,
• Stereotypes
• Perception,
• Social norm
• Words: 1664
• Views: 1,982

Related Topics

• Volunteering
• Juvenile delinquency
• Peer Pressure
• Entrepreneurship
• Behavior Modification
• Exploration

Transformation

• Use of force
• Racial Segregation
• Armenian Genocide
• Justification
• Jim Crow laws

Social Identity Theory in Hy Dairies Case

Case Study 3. 1 HY DAIRIES, INC. Discussion Questions: 1. Apply your knowledge of stereotyping and social identity theory to explain what went wrong here. The case covers issues of how perceptions affect individual decision-making process. As an introduction, Syd Gilman, the vice marketing president at Hy Dairies perceived Rochelle Beauport as a potential marketing staff responsible to improve the sagging sales of Hy’s gourmet ice cream brand, thus decided to reward her with a new post of a marketing research coordinator that was taken by him as a valuable post in marketimg field.

Rochelle Beauport, unfortunately had a different perceptions and expectations that leading her into a difficult decision making situation of whether to confront Gilman on perceived discrimination issue or to leave the company. What went wrong in the case were the organizational conflicts that stemmed from merely misperceptions by Syd Gilman and Rochelle Beauport who had differing background, characteristics and work experiences, thus different social identity.

ready to help you now

Without paying upfront

These, therefore had shaped their differing social identity and engaged them in stereotyping. Gilman misperceived that Beauport would like his proposal because he had previously gone through the process which he adored very much without recognizing Beauport’s different self and social concepts as enlisted below. Factors that developed Gilman’s and Beuport’s stereotypical perceptions: Gilman |Beauport | |Male & white |Woman & colored | |Longevity in Hy Dairies |Newness in Hy Dairies | |Hold a top management post Hold a middle management post | |Career ladder boosted by the marketing research coordinator few |Recent experience with a company that denied women or colored | |years earlier |people in top management; women can’t take the heat in marketing | |Natural assumption that Beauport liked the idea as he too felt |management, thus placed them in technical support positions | |very delighted before when accepting the post |Thoughts- inferiority of the new post ( backroom job & not the | | |route for top management in most | | |organizations) | | |Incomplete information; did not know the boss, thus bewildered to| | |protest | Stereotyping is an extension of social identity theory whereby people make sense of who they are based on their group membership(s) that follows three phases; social categorization, social identification ( homogenization) and social comparison ( diffierentiation). [pic] The first is categorisation. We categorise objects in order to understand them and identify them. In a very similar way we categorise people (including ourselves) in order to understand the social environment.

We use social categories like black, white, Australian, Christian, Muslim, student because they are useful. If we can assign people to a category, then that tells us things about those people. Similarly, we find out things about ourselves by knowing what categories we belong to. We define appropriate behavior by reference to the norms of groups we belong to. Gilman had categorized himself and Beauport as Hy Dairies’ workers who shared the same assumptions, values and beliefs as well as organizational processes. However, since Beauport was new to the organization, Gilman’s perception went astray. In the second stage, social identification, we adopt the identity of the group we have categorised ourselves as belonging to. If for xample you have categorised yourself as a student, the chances are you will adopt the identity of a student and begin to act in the ways you believe students act (and conform to the norms of the group). There will be an emotional significance to your identification with a group, and your self-esteem will become bound up with group membership. Again, Gilman had identified himself and Beauport as Hy Dairies’ member that was not true for Beauport who was very new and in different job hierarchy unlike Gilman. Thus, she did not identify herself with Hy dairies and Gilman. The final stage is social comparison. Once we have categorised ourselves as part of a group and have identified with that group we then tend to compare that group with other groups. If our self-esteem is to be maintained our group needs to compare favourably with other groups.

This is critical to understanding prejudice, because once two groups identify themselves as rivals they are forced to compete in order for the members to maintain their self-esteem. Competition and hostility between groups is thus not only a matter of competing for resources (like in Sherif’s Robbers Cave) like jobs but also the result of competing identities. Referring to the case, since Beauport had not identified herself with Hy Dairies, yet maintained her previous social category, she tended to compare unfavorably against Hy Dairies and Gilman as being prejudiced and bias towards her social category; woman, colored and new organizational member. A stereotype is “… a fixed, over generalised belief about a particular group or class of people. ” (Cardwell, 1996). For example, a “hells angel” biker dresses in leather.

One advantage of a stereotype is that it enables us to respond rapidly to situations because we may have had had a similar experience before. This was evidenced when Gilman quickly concluded on promoting Beauport using his past experience as a bench mark. One disadvantage is that it makes us ignore differences between individuals; therefore we think things about people that might not be true (i. e. make generalisations). Gilman, at many incidences did this and the same as Beauport who generalized so many things about Hy Dairies and Gilman that led her becoming demotivated and stressful. 2. What other perceptual error is apparent in this case study? Recency effect and false-consensus effect are two other perceptual errors that are apparent in this case study.

Recency effect occurs when the most recent information dominates the perceptions. (Mc Shane & Von Glinow, Organizational Behavior, pg 78). This perceptual bias was evident in the case when Beauport, who had limited experience in Hy Dairies’ marketing management evaluated Gilman as being prejudiced and biased using primarily the most similar and recent experience she had before in other organization. False- consensus effect or similar-to-me-effect is a widely observed bias in which we overestimate the extent to which others have beliefs and characteristics similar to our own. Gilman who naturally assumed that Beauport’s surprise of the transfer was her positive response is an evidence of false-consensus effect.

This was because, he too had been delighted several years earlier about his temporary transfer to marketing research. This bias occurs to some extent because Gilman associated Beauport as similar to him and he selectively remember imformation that was consistent with his own views. 3. What can organizations do to minimize misperceptions in these types of situations? The perceptual process cannot be bypassed but organizations must make every attempt to minimize perceptual biases and distortions to reduce unnecessary unfavorable work environment that can affect the organization’s performance and success. In other words, it is impossible to prevent stereotype activation but it is possible to minimize it. The possible strategies will be discussed below.

Diversity awareness training to increase awareness of perceptual biases and improve self-awareness can be undertaken that wiould: – Educate employees about the benefits of diversity and dispel myths about people from various cultural and demographic. This, to a certain extent, would make people more mindful of their thoughts and actions. However, this has a limited effect especially on those who have a deeply held prejudices against out-groups. – Make people more aware of their values, beliefs and prejudices in their behavior and actions. The understanding and awareness would make people more open-minded and non-judgmental toward others. Applying Johari Window is one of the techniques or models for understanding how co-workers can increase their mutual understanding, thus reducing perceptual biases.

Meaningful interaction is there to improve self awareness and mutual understanding. This statement is based on the contact hypothesis, which states that, under certain conditions, people who interact with each other will be less prejudiced or perceptually biased against each other. If this takes place there will be less perceptions and sidelined feelings. To affect this, team cooperation is highly necessary which will activate effective communication. Meaningful interactions does more than reduce the reliance on stereotypes. It also improves empathy, that is the sensitivity to the feelings, thoughts, and situation of others. Decision-making accountability can also minimize perceptual biases and reliance on stereotype.

By making people accountable for their decisions motivates them to consider objective information rather than stereotypes. Objectivity is therefore a medicine to underpin stereotyping. Conclusion: The evidence suggests that what individuals perceive from their work situation will influence their productivity more than will the situation itself. Whether or not a job is actually interesting or challenging is irrelevant. Whether or not a manager successfully plans and organizes the work of his or her employees and actually helps them to structure their work more efficiently and effectively is far less important than how employees perceive the manager’s efforts.

Employees do not judge any behavior and decisions in a way that assures common perceptions, nor can we be assured that individuals will interpret conditions about their jobs in a favorable light. Therefore, to be able to influence productivity, it is necessary to assess how workers perceive their jobs. • A stereotype is a socially held mental picture that represents an oversimplified, prejudiced, or uncritical judgment. • A stereotype threat arises when one is in a situation where one has the fear of doing something that would inadvertently confirm a stereotype. • A stereotype threat is cued by the mere recognition that a negative group stereotype could apply to you in a given situation. It is important to understand that the person may experience a threat even when they do not believe the stereotype. • A stereotype threat generates “spotlight anxiety,” which causes emotional distress and vigilant worry that may undermine performance. • A stereotype threat may induce “attributional ambiguity,” for example, a person gets a low grade and asks, “Is it something about me or because of my race? ” • A stereotype threat comes from the environment, not from some defect inside the person and that research shows it can be corrected by an environmental change. • Intergenerational conflict may account for some behavior that is difficult to understand.

Cite this page

https://graduateway.com/case-3-1-hy-dairies/

You can get a custom paper by one of our expert writers

• Reconstruction
• Social Darwinism
• Body language
• Prison overcrowding
• Self Reflection
• Decision Making
• Impeachment
• Prejudice and discrimination

Check more samples on your topics

Theories of ethnocentrism: social dominance theory and social identity perspective.

Perspective

A major focus of psychology is in understanding why group conflict, inequality and ethnocentrism occur. Many researchers have developed theories and presented evidence to try and explain these issues and two predominant approaches have emerged. The first approach focuses on the relatively stable personality differences that people show in their general orientation towards ethnocentrism and

Jung’s Theory Of Individuation Or Maslow’s Theory Of Self-actualization, Gilgamesh’s Stories And Self Identity

Epic of Gilgamesh

The key to finding one’s true final form of conscious is to combine strength obtained and our capable ability of the mind. To transform and advance one must go through adversity. Stories about growing in the face of challenges are recorded in the past and seen today. Confrontation demands an individual leave convenience behind. This

Critically Evaluate Social Identity Theory

More specifically, we want to understand our social identities and this can be achieved by acknowledging which groups we identify most with. Tajfel and Turner (1986) define this phenomenon of classification within a social context as the Social Identity Theory and it is comprised of three main parts. Zerubevel (as cited in Jenkins, 2004) states

Theory of Social Identity and Party Affiliation

American Identity

There are numerous examples of mass number of the electorate leaving one party and opting for another. A study conducted by the Pew Research Center found that in 2015 almost 25% of young Americans who branded themselves Republican or conservative leaning abandoned their party for the Democrats (Jukam, 2017). Party attachment is a concept that

The Comparison of Behavior Theory, Contingency Theory and Transformational Theory

Leadership is one of the most complex and multifaceted phenomena to which organisational and psychological research has been applied. While the term "leader" was noted as early as the 1300s (The Oxford English Dictionary, 1933) and conceptualised even before biblical times, the term leadership has been in existence only since the late 1700s (Stogdill, 1974). Even

Personal and Social Identity as Depicted in Gail Goodwin’s A Sorrowful Woman Analysis

An identity of person whether defined by himself/herself or by the society is crucial to an individual’s growth, development and survival in life. Identity is linked to culture, heritage, morals, and principles which makes known to everyone to what kind of person he/she is. In literature, the identity of the characters and the identity of

Social Constructionism, Identity and the Concept of Deviance

Construction

Engineering And Construction Industry

Social constructionism, identity, and the concept of deviance are closely interconnected. According to social constructionist theory (SCT), our understanding of the world is constructed through daily social interactions. SCT also proposes that individuals actively construct their identities using social tools, with language being the primary means. This theory views identity as both conditional and self-motivated,

Identity of Social Work

Essays Database

Social work

Individuality is an aspect that constantly changes as you figure out what career path you are looking for and what professional life you pick. People can classify a bunch of characteristics of who they want to be. The setup of social workers identities include characteristics of social workers, whereas professional identity can be formed and

Positive and Negative Effects of Social Media on Teenage Identity, Relationships, and Personal Growth

Adolescence

With the advent of social media comes new opportunities for young people to communicate and express themselves. Through these channels, teenagers develop and mature in new ways that are not fully understood by many of the adults in their lives. By examining the development, behaviors, relationships, and attitudes of teenagers who use social media, one

Hi, my name is Amy 👋

In case you can't find a relevant example, our professional writers are ready to help you write a unique paper. Just talk to our smart assistant Amy and she'll connect you with the best match.